Impact Doors vs Traditional Doors Cost Comparison

When selecting doors for your home, there are numerous factors to consider—from aesthetics and functionality to safety and cost. Among the different types available, impact doors and traditional doors are frequently compared. Understanding the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison can help homeowners make an informed decision that aligns with their needs and budget.

Table of Contents

What are Traditional Doors?

What are Impact Doors?

Impact-Resistant Doors vs Traditional Doors Cost Comparison

How to Save Cost on Door Installation

FAQs

Key Takeaways Impact doors offer higher safety and durability than traditional doors. Initial costs for impact doors are offset by long-term savings. Traditional doors cost less upfront but may require more maintenance. Energy efficiency is significantly better with impact doors installed. Insurance premiums can decrease with the installation of impact doors. Impact doors can be customized to fit any home style. Warranties for impact doors often cover glass breakage and seals. Investing in impact doors increases a home’s resale value effectively.

What are Traditional Doors?

When exploring the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison, it’s crucial to understand the distinctions in construction and performance between the two. Traditional doors, commonly called normal or builder’s standard, are the most prevalent type used in residential and commercial buildings. These doors consist of two outer skins or panels with an insulating filler in between, which helps with thermal regulation and noise reduction. The materials used in traditional doors can vary widely, but the most common are:

• Wood: Offers a classic and warm aesthetic, widely chosen for its natural look and the ability to be painted or stained to match any decor.
• Aluminum: Known for its durability and lightweight, aluminum is corrosion-resistant and requires minimal maintenance.
• Combination of materials: Some traditional doors combine materials like wood and aluminum to leverage both benefits, such as improved structural integrity and aesthetic appeal.

Traditional doors also have a designated spot for lock installation, enhancing their security capabilities. However, it’s important to note that while they undergo standard security testing, they may not withstand extreme weather conditions like heavy rains and high winds as well as impact-resistant doors do. The frame and material of traditional doors, especially wood and aluminum, could crack or shatter under such conditions.

Benefits of Traditional Doors

• Cost-Effectiveness: Generally less expensive than high-security and impact-resistant options, making them accessible for a wide range of budgets.
• Aesthetic Variety: Available in many styles, designs, and finishes to complement any architectural style.
• Customization: Easy to customize with paints, stains, and hardware to match the homeowner’s taste and home’s exterior.
• Ease of Repair: Simpler construction makes them easier to repair than more complex door systems.
• Sufficient Security: Offers adequate security for everyday use in areas not prone to severe weather conditions.

Traditional doors are a functional and economical choice for many homeowners, balancing cost with performance for typical residential applications. However, for those in regions susceptible to severe weather, the long-term benefits and resilience of impact-resistant doors might outweigh the initial savings of traditional doors.

Cost of Traditional Doors

Traditional doors are a staple in new constructions and renovations, offering functionality and aesthetic appeal. The cost of traditional doors varies widely based on the type, material, and specific features you choose. On average, homeowners spend about $1,164 on traditional door installations, but prices can range from as low as $496 to as high as $1,879.

Cost Installation by Style

When comparing the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison, it’s also useful to consider the installation costs by the style of the traditional doors:

• Standard Single Door: Installation costs for a simple single door can range from $200 to $1,800. This broad range reflects the straightforward nature of standard doors but varies based on material and design complexity.
• Double Doors: For more grandiose entryways, double doors installation costs between $750 and $5,000. Costs can increase significantly if structural changes are necessary, especially if installing them in a load-bearing wall.
• French Doors: Known for their aesthetic appeal and multiple glass panes, French doors installation costs range from $600 to $5,800. They are often installed as double doors in historic or upscale homes.
• Sliding Doors: Sliding doors, which include variations such as soundproof or hurricane impact doors, generally cost between $500 and $4,500 to install. The price depends largely on the specific type and features of the sliding door chosen.
• Bifold Doors: Interior bifold doors, typically used for closets, range from $150 to $500 for installation. Exterior bifold doors, ideal for connecting indoor spaces to outdoor areas like patios, can be much more costly, with installation prices ranging from $4,000 to $12,000.
• Bulkhead Cellar Doors: Used primarily for exterior basement entries, bulkhead doors cost between $600 and $1,200 for the door itself, with total costs including installation ranging from $1,100 to $6,000.
• Screen Doors: Ideal for letting in breezes while keeping bugs out, screen door installations cost typically around $300, with a range from $100 to $1,500 based on material and size.
• Barn Doors: These can be used both inside for a rustic touch or outside for traditional utility, with costs ranging from $200 to $5,000, depending on customization and size.
• Pocket Doors: Perfect for saving space, pocket door installations cost between $500 and $3,500. The cost varies significantly depending on the structural modifications needed for the surrounding walls.
• Pet Doors: Installation costs range from $100 to $500 for an existing door, or up to $2,000 for a new door setup that accommodates pets.

What are Impact Doors?

Impact doors offer superior protection against severe weather events like hurricanes and tropical storms. Unlike standard doors, impact doors are constructed with heavy-duty frames and laminated glass to withstand high winds and flying debris. The laminated glass comprises two glass panes bonded with a clear, strong interlayer, typically made of polyvinyl butyral (PVB) or ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA). This composition prevents the glass from shattering into dangerous shards upon impact.

In the context of an impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison, it’s important to also consider impact doors, as they complement impact doors in enhancing a home’s security and resilience.

Benefits of Impact Doors

• Enhanced Safety: Provides strong resistance against debris and high winds, ensuring the integrity of the window even during severe storms.
• Energy Efficiency: Offers excellent insulation, reducing the cost of heating and cooling by maintaining a consistent internal temperature.
• UV Protection: The laminated glass used in impact doors filters out harmful UV rays, protecting interior furnishings and flooring from fading.
• Noise Reduction: The robust construction helps reduce outside noise, making them ideal for homes in busy or noisy environments.
• Increased Property Value: Installing impact doors can enhance a home’s resale value, appealing to buyers who value safety and energy efficiency.

When evaluating the cost comparison of impact doors vs. traditional doors, it is essential to consider the complementary impact doors. The doors’ initial investment is often offset by their long-term benefits, including potential savings on insurance premiums due to their protective features.

Cost of Impact Doors

When considering home improvements for enhanced safety and efficiency, the cost comparison of impact doors vs. traditional doors becomes an essential discussion. Impact doors, designed to withstand severe weather conditions like hurricanes, generally have a higher initial cost than traditional doors. The price range for non-custom impact doors typically falls between $2,400 and $3,000, depending on various factors, including style and material choices.

Breakdown of Costs

1. Material Costs

• The major portion of the expense in impact doors arises from the materials used. For instance, a 72×80 sliding glass patio door that features simple aluminum framing and large areas of impact-resistant glass tends to be at the higher end of the price spectrum due to the cost of the specialized glass.

• Alternatively, French entryway doors might be relatively less expensive because they often require less glass. Material expenses for impact doors start at around $1,000 but can exceed $2,000 depending on the choice of glass, wood, or metal components.

2. Labor Costs

• The installation process for impact doors is comparable to that of traditional doors. However, due to their heavier and more robust construction, labor costs might be slightly higher to accommodate the extra skill and time needed for installation.

Impact-Resistant Doors vs Traditional Doors Cost Comparison

When choosing between impact-resistant and traditional doors in Florida, USA, homeowners must weigh the costs and benefits to determine which option best suits their needs and budget.

Initial Purchase and Installation Costs

One of the first considerations in the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison is the upfront cost associated with purchasing and installing these doors. Impact-resistant doors typically carry a higher price tag, costing about 25% to 50% more than traditional doors. This price difference is due to the advanced materials and technology needed to enhance their durability and effectiveness against severe weather and potential break-ins. While the initial expense is higher, enhanced safety and durability benefits often justify the cost for many homeowners, especially those in areas prone to harsh weather conditions.

Maintenance Costs Over Time

Considering long-term costs is crucial in the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison. Impact-resistant doors are designed for longevity and resilience, translating into lower maintenance needs. Their robust construction enables them to withstand environmental stresses far better than traditional doors, which may require more frequent repairs or replacements. This difference is particularly noticeable in extreme weather areas where traditional doors might suffer wear and tear more quickly. Over time, the reduced maintenance and replacement costs can make impact-resistant doors a more cost-effective choice despite their higher initial investment.

Energy Efficiency and Related Savings

Energy efficiency is another important factor in the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison. Impact-resistant doors are often built with better insulating properties, including sealed frames and multi-layer glass that minimize heat transfer. This enhanced insulation helps maintain consistent indoor temperatures, reducing the workload on heating and cooling systems and potentially lowering energy costs significantly. In contrast, traditional doors may not provide the same level of insulation, leading to higher energy expenses.

Insurance Premiums and Discounts

Homeowners who install impact-resistant doors can also enjoy financial benefits through reduced insurance premiums. Many insurers offer discounts for homes with features that improve safety and reduce risk, such as impact-resistant doors. These discounts range from 10% to 15% and are generally unavailable for homes with traditional doors. In storm-prone regions, having impact-resistant doors can be particularly financially advantageous through direct insurance savings and by complying with local building codes or insurance requirements that favor or mandate reinforced doors.

How to Save Cost on Door Installation

Installing new doors can be a significant investment, especially considering high-quality options like impact doors. However, several strategies can help you save on the door installation cost, making impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison more favorable.

Choose the Right Time for Installation

Timing can greatly affect the cost of installation. Off-peak seasons for contractors, typically during late fall or early winter, may offer lower rates as demand for installation services decreases. Scheduling your door installation during these times can lead to better deals and more attentive service.

Compare Quotes

It’s essential to gather and compare multiple quotes from different contractors. This gives you a clearer picture of the fair market price for door installation in your area. When doing an impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison, ensure that the quotes are comprehensive, including all potential fees for labor, materials, and any additional costs that might arise.

DIY What You Can

For traditional doors, consider handling some simpler tasks yourself, such as removing the old door or finishing touches like painting or staining. This can reduce the amount of paid labor required. However, for impact doors, due to their complexity and the precision needed for proper installation, it is recommended to limit DIY efforts to preparatory work to ensure that the installation meets safety standards.

Use Existing Frames If Possible

If the existing door frames are in good condition, you can save money by installing new doors into the existing framework. This is often feasible when doing an impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison as long as the new door specifications match the old frame. This strategy eliminates the need for frame reconstruction, which can be costly.

Hire a Professional Installer

Hiring a professional installer is advisable for optimal results in the impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison. Skilled professionals like  Prestige Windows and Doors ensure proper installation, which is crucial for door functionality and durability. Although initially more expensive, this can prevent costly future repairs caused by incorrect installation, such as air leaks or security issues. Investing in expert installation can ultimately save money and enhance door performance.

FAQs

How long do impact doors last compared to traditional doors?

Impact doors are built to last longer than traditional doors due to their durable materials and construction. While the lifespan of any door depends on factors like material quality and maintenance, impact doors generally offer better longevity, especially in harsh weather conditions.

Do impact doors require special maintenance?

Impact doors typically require less maintenance than traditional doors because they are designed to resist weathering and wear. Regular cleaning and occasional checks of seals and hardware to ensure everything is functioning properly are usually sufficient for maintaining their condition and performance.

Can I install impact doors on any type of home?

Yes, impact doors can be installed on any home, regardless of construction style or age. They are a versatile option that can replace existing doors without needing significant structural modifications, making them suitable for both new constructions and retrofits.

What styles of impact doors are available?

Impact doors come in various styles, including French, sliding glass, and even decorative entry doors. Manufacturers have expanded their offerings to include numerous designs that can complement any architectural style, ensuring that homeowners do not have to compromise on aesthetics for safety.

What warranty options are available for impact doors?

Impact doors typically come with extensive warranty options that cover everything from the glass to the frame and hardware. Warranties vary significantly between manufacturers but often include coverage for seal integrity, glass breakage, and frame durability. Reviewing warranty details before purchase is important to understand what protections are included and any applicable conditions. These robust warranties can be a decisive factor in the impact doors vs. traditional doors cost comparison, as they add long-term value and peace of mind for the investment.

Invest in Safety and Efficiency with Impact Doors From Prestige Windows and Doors 

When evaluating impact doors vs traditional doors cost comparison, it’s important to consider the long-term benefits of choosing impact doors. These benefits include enhanced safety, improved energy efficiency, and lower insurance premiums. Although the initial cost is higher, the investment in impact doors ultimately pays off by protecting your home and reducing maintenance expenses.

For those considering upgrading their home’s doors in Florida, USA, Prestige Windows and Doors offers a wide selection of high-quality impact doors. Trust Prestige to provide durable and stylish door solutions that meet your specific needs. 

Contact us today!